Door County vacation rental cohosting for waterfront owners.
Baylake Vacation Rentals is an owner-run cohosting company. We run the property — listings, pricing, guests, turnovers and preventive maintenance — while you keep ownership of the accounts and receive guest funds directly. We are a hospitality and marketing agent, not a property manager holding your money.
Four disciplines, written down, run every week.
The work is documented so the standard holds when the week is busy. That is the whole argument. How it works has the 21-day install and the written scope.
Revenue
Priced weekly against the real comp set — not a seasonal calendar set once in March. Minimum-night and gap rules are tuned through the year. The extra revenue lives in the shoulder weeks and the compression events average management misses.
Marketing
The listing is rebuilt, not merely maintained. Photos, title and copy are re-cut for whoever is actually searching that month. Each home gets its own brand, domain and direct-booking site, listed in sync on Airbnb, Vrbo, Booking.com and Google Vacation Rentals, under your accounts.
Hospitality
Stocking, linens and messaging run from a checklist, so the fortieth stay of the season looks like the first. A person answers when something is actually wrong, including at 11pm.
Maintenance
StayReady, our sister operation, runs a 266-point inspection on a schedule rather than after a guest reports a failure. We can perform the work, not only coordinate a vendor. StayReady's published plans start at $59 a month; Guest-Safe is $159. Baylake's $199 monthly retainer is that Guest-Safe layer plus priority response as a Baylake property.
Waterfront or near-water Door County homes, mostly for owners who don't live here.
We visit every property personally, so the book is capped: five properties this first year. When the five are placed, the list closes until we can staff past it honestly. Service area: southern and central Door County — Sturgeon Bay, Little Sturgeon, Sawyer Harbor, Idlewild, Egg Harbor and the shoreline between. If you're further up the peninsula, ask — the answer depends on whether we can keep the visit schedule honest.
A fit
Three bedrooms or more, and realistically capable of $100,000 a year or more. Owners in Green Bay, Milwaukee, Madison or Chicago — far enough that the drive up to meet a contractor costs a day. Owners who want the asset run properly, not the cheapest fee.
Not a fit
Anyone shopping purely on percentage. Properties where the analysis doesn't show meaningful upside — we'll tell you and we won't take the property. Owners who want to stay hands-on daily: the system only works if it's allowed to run.
What it costs
15% of gross rents up to what your property made last year, 25% on everything above that, plus a $199 monthly retainer. $995 setup, once. The founding five sign on those Baseline & Upside terms, with the baseline fixed for three seasons. The worked examples are published.
We tested this with our own two cottages first.
Rocky Shores Retreat (3 bedrooms, 1 bath, sleeps 10, on Little Sturgeon Bay, launched August 2021) and Sawyer Harbor Retreat (2 bedrooms plus loft, 2 baths, sleeps 10, on Sawyer Harbor, launched June 2022). Combined booked revenue from our OwnerRez records, including cleaning fees: $173,699 to $211,249 a year over five seasons, or 2.2×–2.6× a combined $80,000 full-year AirDNA projection. 2026 is confirmed bookings as of 16 November 2026. These results are for properties we own and are not a guarantee for any other property. Read the five-season record, or get the 8-page case study.
