Baylake Vacation Rentals Revenue X-Ray
Free owner tool · 20 questions · about four minutes

How well is your rental really being run?

Whether a manager runs your Door County home or you do it yourself, these twenty yes-or-no questions are the ones we'd ask on a walk-through. Answer honestly — “not sure” is an answer too, and often the most telling one.

Pricing & revenue

01 Nightly rates are reviewed at least weekly — not just set once a season.
02 Minimum-stay rules change with the season and open up for short gaps.
03 At least once a season you see how your occupancy and rate compare with the local market.
04 Open nights in the next two weeks are priced to fill rather than left empty.

Listing & marketing

05 The listing photos were professionally shot or refreshed in the last two years.
06 The title and description were rewritten in the last twelve months.
07 The home is on at least two booking channels, or has its own direct-booking site.
08 You own the guest list: past guests can be contacted to book again directly.

Guest experience

09 Guest messages are answered within an hour, evenings and weekends included.
10 The average rating over the last twelve months is 4.8 or higher.
11 Every review gets a thoughtful written response.
12 Guests get a local guidebook before they arrive.

Property care

13 Someone walks through the home just to inspect it — not to clean — at least quarterly.
14 Cleaners report damage and low supplies, with photos, after every turnover.
15 There's a written maintenance schedule for the furnace, water heater, septic or well, and gutters.
16 Winterizing and spring opening follow a checklist that someone signs off.

Reporting & ownership

17 You get a monthly statement showing revenue, fees and expenses line by line.
18 You know last year's occupancy and average nightly rate without having to ask.
19 The listing accounts are in your name, and guest payouts land in your account.
20 You can see this year's revenue against last year's, month by month.

0 of 20 answered

Why these twenty

Underperformance is usually a management problem

Two Door County homes with the same bedrooms and the same water can be tens of thousands of dollars apart at the end of a season. The difference rarely shows up in the photos. It shows up in how often the price changes, who answers the 10 p.m. message, and whether anyone has looked at the furnace since spring.

The scorecard weights all five areas equally. A yes earns full marks, not sure earns partial credit, and no earns none — because an owner who can't answer a question about their own home usually has the answer already.