Baylake Vacation Rentals Revenue X-Ray
Free owner tool · two minutes · real market data

What should your Door County rental earn?

Five questions. We'll show you where your home sits against 86 comparable Door County rentals — the typical home, the top quarter, and the top ten percent — using last year's actual booking data.

Your property

Total guest payments including cleaning fees, before your manager's cut. A rough number is fine.

What you'll see
  • Where you rank against the typical Door County home your size, the top quarter and the top ten percent.
  • Your dollar gap to the next tier — the money a better-run year would add.
  • The month-by-month curve, so you can see whether you're losing it in July or in the shoulders.
How the estimate works

Built on booked nights, not projections

The benchmarks come from PriceLabs market data on the 86 three-bedroom Airbnb listings around Sturgeon Bay, covering November 2025 – October 2026. Over that year the typical listing was booked 49.5% of available nights at an average of $302 a night — about $54,600 a year.

The top quarter ($82,100) and top ten percent ($104,500) show what the same occupancy earns when a home prices like the upper quarter and upper tenth of the market. Four-bedroom figures scale by 1.3×, from booked rates in the smaller 4-bedroom sample. We don't add a waterfront premium — we'd rather show it on your actual comps.

It's an estimate, not an appraisal. Data outside the Sturgeon Bay area is thinner, and five-bedroom homes are too few to benchmark honestly; the free Revenue X-Ray builds a comp set for your exact property instead.