Baylake Vacation Rentals Revenue X-Ray
Southern and central Door County

Waterfront vacation rental management in Door County.

Baylake cohosts a small book of waterfront and near-water homes for out-of-town owners. We own two of them ourselves: a bay cottage on Little Sturgeon and a harbor cottage on Sawyer Harbor. The operating standard was built on shoreline property, not applied to it later.

Why waterfront is a different job

A shoreline home can earn a premium. It can also fail in ways a town house never will.

Docks, kayaks, ice, storms, seasonal open and close, and guests who came for the water — these are ordinary facts of a Door County waterfront rental. They are also the failures that show up in reviews when maintenance is reactive. StayReady's 266-point protocol is how we look for those failures before a guest does. We inspect on a schedule and can perform the work on site, rather than only dispatching a vendor after a complaint.

We do not publish a separate waterfront “uplift” statistic. What we can show is the record on the two shoreline cottages we own, and the system that produced it. The five-season record is the evidence; a Revenue X-Ray is how we put a number on a property like yours.

Two cottages, two bodies of water

The proof of the idea is that our own two properties don't sound alike.

Rocky Shores Retreat on the Green Bay shore at Little Sturgeon

Little Sturgeon · Green Bay shore

Rocky Shores Retreat

3 bedrooms, 1 bath, sleeps 10, about 1,320 square feet, launched August 2021. Ledge rock, open water, big sunsets. Its own site, its own returning guests. rockyshoresretreat.com

Sawyer Harbor Retreat on Sawyer Harbor, south of Sturgeon Bay

Sawyer Harbor · south of Sturgeon Bay

Sawyer Harbor Retreat

2 bedrooms plus loft, 2 baths, sleeps 10, about 1,400 square feet, launched June 2022. Sheltered bay, dock, lawn to the water. A different guest entirely. sawyerharborretreat.com

Open both. Read the difference, not the quality — two homes run by one company should not sound like the same house. That is the Property of One.

Service area

Sturgeon Bay, Little Sturgeon, Sawyer Harbor, Idlewild, Egg Harbor, and the shoreline between.

If you're further up the peninsula, ask — we visit every property personally, and five is the number we can keep that promise on this first year. The founding five are waterfront or near-water homes, three bedrooms or more, realistically capable of $100,000 a year or more.